Defense doesn’t always get the spotlight in MLB The Show 25, but experienced players know that one clutch catch or perfectly timed shift can flip the momentum of a game. Whether you're grinding through Ranked mode or just trying to tighten things up in Franchise, the following 12 defensive adjustments can help you secure more wins and save crucial runs.
1. Shift Based on Tendencies, Not Just Ratings
Don't blindly rely on auto-shifts. Use the batter's spray chart and tendencies to create your own shifts. Custom positioning often makes the difference between a single and an out.
2. Manual Throws Over Auto Assist
Switching to full manual throwing gives you more control during high-pressure plays. It takes practice, but the precision it offers can be a game-changer—especially during double plays or cut-off throws.
3. Use the Right Archetype for Fielding
Fielding-focused archetypes come with superior reaction, speed, and arm accuracy. If you’re playing Road to the Show, investing in one of these builds early on saves you from costly mistakes later.
4. Take Advantage of Pre-Pitch Positioning
MLB The Show 25 allows you to adjust each fielder’s starting spot manually. Move outfielders in for contact hitters or shade them toward opposite fields. It’s a subtle adjustment with major impact.
5. Train Your Reaction Timing in Practice Mode
Many errors stem from slow reactions. Spend time in fielding practice drills to improve your muscle memory and reduce hesitation during in-game scenarios.
6. Sub in Defensive Specialists Late Game
Just like in real baseball, bringing in players with elite fielding ratings in late innings can close the door on opponents. A few runs saved can equal a few more wins by season’s end.
7. Know Your Ballpark Dimensions
Different stadiums play differently. A deep center in one park might be shallow in another. Learn wall heights and foul territory so you can position outfielders more strategically.
8. Switch to Button Accuracy Throwing
If you’re still using buttons-only or analog throws, it’s time to upgrade. Button Accuracy gives you the ability to aim perfectly for green and avoid costly throwing errors.
9. Boost Fielding Stats with Equipment
Especially in Diamond Dynasty, equipping players with fielding-enhancing gear boosts performance. You don’t need to buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs to get decent equipment—grinding programs can reward you with valuable gear.
10. Customize Defensive Settings Per Game Mode
Franchise and Diamond Dynasty often require different defensive approaches. In Franchise, you may prefer simulation-friendly auto-fielding. In Ranked, manual control offers a competitive edge.
11. Use Defensive Substitutions with Pitching Matchups in Mind
When bringing in relievers, think about how the opposing batter might hit. Then adjust your infield and outfield accordingly to prevent gaps and optimize playmaking.
12. Be Smart with Stubs for Defensive Players
Don’t blow all your resources on flashy sluggers. Sometimes the smartest use of MLB 25 Stubs Xbox users can make is investing in undervalued defenders. Platforms like U4N often offer insight into market trends without needing to overspend.
In MLB The Show 25, flashy offense may get the highlights, but smart defensive play wins close games. Mastering these 12 adjustments won’t just make you a better fielder—they’ll help you outsmart your opponents and rise in the ranks without needing to constantly chase upgrades. Whether you're stockpiling MLB 25 Stubs Xbox or fine-tuning your custom squad, a stronger defense means more consistent success on the field.